Detail from BL Royal 18 D ii, fol. 30v, by permission of the British Library. Click the thumbnail to see more about this MS.
King Arthur and Fortune
Siân Echard, University of British Columbia
|English 344 home page|
Early in the Historia regum Britannie, Leir berates Fortune as he muses on the contrast between his current wretchedness and his past glories:
A major source for the medieval view of Fortune is Consolatio Philosophiae, by Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius, a noble Roman who was executed in 524. The Consolation is set in prison, as the speaker, awaiting death, laments the change in his fortunes. Lady Philosophy appears to him, and tells him that a wise men does not put his faith in Fortune, even when she is helping him: it is the nature of Fortune to change. Here is Philosophy’s description of the ways of Fortune:
Philosophy’s Fortuna can govern both kings and peasants, but later medieval fortune narratives seem particularly fascinated with the fall of the great. An example of this fascination is the Middle English poet John Lydgate’s Fall of Princes. Click here to see a manuscript of this poem at the University of Victoria. Lydgate based his work on Giovanni Boccaccio’s De casibus virorum illustrium (On the fall of famous men).
By the time of the Alliterative and Stanzaic Morte Arthure, discussed further below, dreams of negative fortune include the familiar iconography of Fortuna and her wheel. But even before Fortune and her wheel are explicitly invoked, prophetic dreams often include a fall from great height. Arthur’s dream of the dragon and bear in Geoffrey’s Historia is one example (and it recurs in, for example, the Alliterative Morte Arthure and in Malory’s Morte). Another is the dream that Arthur has after his victory over Lucius in La3amon’s Brut, an early 13th-century chronicle version of Geoffrey’s Historia which also drew on the adaptation made by the Anglo-Norman poet Wace. This particular dream is apparently La3amon’s invention, however.
The extract that follows offers the Middle English on the left and a translation on the right. Because of concerns about browser fonts, I have had to change some of the letters to modern equivalents, so that thorn is represented by th, and eth by d or th. The extract begins at line 13982.
Toniht a mine slepe, ther ich laei on bure,
me imaette a sweuen; theruoure ich ful sari aem.
Me imette that mon me hof uppen are halle;
Tha halle ich gon bistriden swulc ich wolde riden;
alle tha lond tha ich ah alle ich there ouer sah,
and Walwain sat biuoren me; mi sweord he bar an honde.
Tha com Moddred daren there mid unimete uolke;
he bar an his honde ane wiax stronge.
He bigon to hewene hardliche swithe
and tha postes forheou alle tha heolden up tha halle.
Ther ich iseh Wehneuer eke, wimmonnen leofest me;
al there muche halle rod mid hire honden heo todroh.
Tha halle gon to haelden and ich haeld to grunden
that mi riht aerm tobrac. Tha seide Modred Haue that!
adun ueol tha halle, and Walwain gon to ualle
and feol a there eorthe; his aermes brekeen beine.
And ich igrap mi sweord leofe mid mire leoft honde,
and smaet of Modred is hafd that hit wond a thene ueld.
And tha quene ich al tosnadde mid deore mine sweorede;
and seothen ich heo adun sette in ane swarte putte.
Tonight in my sleep, as I lay in my chamber,
I dreamed a dream; I am very uneasy from it.
I dreamed that I had been put high up on a hall:
I bestrode the hall as if I were riding.
All the land that belongs to me I looked over from there,
and Gawain sat before me, bearing my sword in his hand.
Then Modred came marching there with an enormous host;
he bore a stout battleaxe in his hand.
He began to hew very strongly
and he cut through all the posts that held up the hall.
There I also saw Guenevere, the dearest of women to me;
she pulled down the whole roof of that great hall with her hands.
The hall began to fall, and I fell to the ground
so that my right arm broke. Then Modred said Have that!
The hall fell down, and Gawain began to fall
and fell to the earth; his arms were broken.
And I gripped my beloved sword in my left hand,
and smote off Modred's head, so that it fell to the ground.
And I cut the queen all to pieces with my dear sword;
and then I thrust her down into a dark pit.
|The dream in La3amon contains the reversal of Fortune, and (like Leir’s lament in Geoffrey’s Historia), is particularly focused on the change from rule to a loss of land or power. There is not, however, any overt condemnation here of the conqueror who in turn becomes the conquered. Compare the invocation of the motif of Fortune’s Wheel in The Awntyrs off Arthur, in which Gawain asks the ghost of Guenevere’s mother how Arthurian knights will fare in the afterlife. The extract below shows that he couches his question in terms of participation in unjust conquest; and the ghost responds in a way that links Fortune to Arthur’s covetousness. In this view, the vagaries of Fortune are fitting punishment for overweening pride or ambition.|
“How shal we fare,” quod the freke, “that fonden to fight,
(The Awntyrs off Arthure, 261-73; you can read the whole text online by clicking here)
The image to the left from BL MS Harley 4376, fol. 231r, showing Alexander the Great on Fortune’s Wheel, appears by permission of the British Library. Click the thumbnail to see more about this manuscript.
The association of Arthur’s fall with Fortune and her wheel is developed into a prophetic dream in the 13th-century French prose La Mort le Roi Artu, a text which was adapted into English in the 14th century as the Stanzaic Morte Arthure. Compare these dreams:
When Arthur had fallen asleep, he dreamt that a lady came before him, the most beautiful he had ever seen in the world, who lifted him up from the ground and took him up into the highest mountain he had ever seen. There she placed him on a wheel, on which there were seats, some rising and some falling. The king looked to see at which part of the wheel he was sitting, and saw he was at the highest point.
The lady asked him, “Arthur, where are you?”
“My lady,” he replied, “I am on a high wheel, but I do not know what kind of a wheel it is.”
“It is the wheel of Fortune,” she replied. Then she asked him, “Arthur, what can you see?”
“My lady, I think I can see the whole world.”
“That is true,” she said, “you can see it, and there is very little of which you have not been lord up till now. Of all the circle you can see you have been the most powerful king there ever was. But such is earthly pride that no one is seated so high that he can avoid having to fall from power in the world.”
Then she took him and pushed him to the ground so roughly that King Arthur felt that he had broken all his bones in the fall and had lost the use of his body and limbs.
Arthur’s dream in the Alliterative Morte Arthure puts kings on the wheel, and Arthur’s philosopher tells him that these were famous conquerors: he names them as Alexander, Hector, Julius Caesar, Judas Maccabeus, Joshua, David, Charlemagne, and Godfrey de Bouillon; these are 8 of the so-called Nine Worthies. Arthur is the ninth (though he is chronologically earlier than either Charlemagne or Godfrey, of course). The motif of the Nine Worthies derives from an early 14th-century French poem called the Voeux du Paon (Vows of the Peacock). There are 3 classical heroes; 3 biblical heroes; and 3 Christian heroes.
The Cloisters Collection in New York includes part of a tapestry which represents Arthur among the Worthies; click the thumbnail to the left to go to the Metropolitan Museum of Art website description of the Nine Worthies Tapestries.
|English 344 home page|